Trashing Integrity, ’81
I heard this story from my friend Bob Wolf, former chairman of Chiat/Day, who I worked with on the Columbia Pictures account at Wells, Rich, Greene. One day, Bob and one of our copywriters drove out to Burbank to present an ad campaign for an upcoming Columbia picture to the marketing director. It was edgy and irreverant, and he absolutely loved it.
But what would his more conservative bosses think? “This is fucking great.” said the marketing director. “I don’t give a shit what my management says. This campaign will run. And if they don’t buy it, I’ll fucking quit!”
Bob and the writer drove back to the agency feeling the warm glow of victory – until later that day when the client called and said the campaign was dead. “What!” Bob said, “I can’t believe it. This afternoon you were ready to stake your career on this campaign.” “I know” he said. “But my boss thought it sucked, and I couldn’t bring myself to argue with him”. “Jesus” said Bob “Where do you get your integrity?” Without missing a beat, the client said, “Where do I get my integrity, Bob? Let me tell you a story.”
He said, “George Segal was a big star whose movies made a lot of money for this studio. Then he developed a little drug problem. One day, George gets stoned and decides he wants to see our president, but our president can’t see him because he’s at lunch with some important people.
So, George goes ape shit. He barges into the president’s office, knocks over plants, dumps cigarette butts on the fancy shmancy carpet, rips pictures off of walls—- he really trashes the place. When our president comes back from lunch and sees what George has done, he becomes enraged and says to the entire executive committee, ‘George Segal will never work for this studio again!”
“Well, it seems that George went on to have a big hit movie with another studio and was back on top again. And one year to the day later, our president hired George Segal to star in Columbia’s next big blockbuster.” With that, the marketing director looked Bob directly in the eye and said, “Where do I get my integrity, Bob? Right from the top!”
Like my stories? Please comment here or send questions to howie@madmensch.com. And if you like it, spread it.
© 2010 Howard Cohen, All Rights Reserved
Posted: May 25th, 2010 under Advertising.
Comments
Comment from Mad Mensch
Time May 26, 2010 at 7:36 am
Unfortunately, I agree with most of what you say. Although, the masturbation wasn’t always mental.
Comment from Jen
Time May 26, 2010 at 11:03 am
Well said…
Comment from Rebecca
Time May 26, 2010 at 4:48 pm
“Mentally masturbate”… Just hearing that makes my head tingle.
Comment from Mad Mensch
Time May 26, 2010 at 4:57 pm
Even more tingly when you have a fertile mind.
Comment from Rebecca
Time May 26, 2010 at 10:14 pm
Ahh yes, a fertile mind is a terrible thing to waste.
Comment from Bob Nadler
Time May 27, 2010 at 7:35 am
The mental masturbation part was usually dependent upon
whom your partner was and if anybody was within earshot.
Comment from Rebecca
Time May 27, 2010 at 9:50 am
It’s a brilliant line… If I came up with it I’d be darn proud!
Comment from Andrea Giambrone
Time May 27, 2010 at 4:41 pm
Just because it’s limp, doesn’t mean it can’t appreciate the CONCEPT of rising.
Comment from Mad Mensch
Time May 27, 2010 at 8:05 pm
And some concepts are bigger than others.
Comment from London Crane
Time August 19, 2011 at 7:46 am
No wonder why Google search result advert specialist Themelis Cuiper notified me with a book mark to this story – you must be doing an exceptional job as he is pointing towards you? :>

Comment from Bob Nadler
Time May 26, 2010 at 7:32 am
The words advertising and integrity are like military intelligence. They are an oxymoron. Advertising is an audience participation sport in which the ignorant and incompetent are given the power to destroy brilliance in favor of banality.
Advertising has become a game called TEGWAR ( The exciting game without rules) where logic and innovation take a back seat to client and agency comfort level.
Behind every great piece of advertising today, you’ll find a client who is either smart enough or dumb enough to allow
those who create great advertising to mentally masturbate their way to brilliance.
It is one thing to create a brilliant piece of advertising. It is
another to sell it.